The SF Chronicle today came out against Berkeley for wanting to protect itself against excessive housing congestion, calling Berkeley hypocritical and dominated by NIMBYism. As usual, the Chron sucks.
https://www.sfchronicle.com/opinion/editorials/article/Editorial-BART-housing-bill-exposes-lots-of-12955524.php
I thought it deserved a reply, although the Chron is notorious for the worst Letters to the Editor section perhaps in the country. The Maui News has better written letters. Nonetheless, here's what I wrote -- read it here because you can be assured you won't be able to see it in the Chron, because for one thing, it is grammatically correct....
https://www.sfchronicle.com/opinion/editorials/article/Editorial-BART-housing-bill-exposes-lots-of-12955524.php
I thought it deserved a reply, although the Chron is notorious for the worst Letters to the Editor section perhaps in the country. The Maui News has better written letters. Nonetheless, here's what I wrote -- read it here because you can be assured you won't be able to see it in the Chron, because for one thing, it is grammatically correct....
re Editorial: Bill reveals lots of
hypocrisy
NIMBYism my backside! Do Weiner, Chiu,
and your editorial board want to Manhattan-ize our communities and
destroy their character because “people want to live there?” Why
castigate current residents of functional communities who want to
preserve what is good in the world? Let's remember the mistakes of
well-meaning urban redevelopers of the last century who inadvertently
destroyed communities they called “slums.”
Yes, people need to live somewhere, but
we should widen our view and think of the crisis not as one of
housing, but rather of transportation. Shrinking commuting times by
expanding and expediting trains, busses and BART connections would
allow peripheral communities to flourish, and would avoid the
contagion of ever more congestion. Yes, this would require expanded
public investment and preferential treatment of public
transportation, and some imagination by transportation planners, but
other countries have gone this way. Why not us?
Budd Shenkin
No comments:
Post a Comment