The Insistent Relevance of Humanistic Medicine
The mission of medicine has traditionally been to cure when you can, but to care always. The progress of curing with scientific biomedicine (BioM) in recent years has been revolutionary. By contrast, the present and future of the caring function, which we can call humanistic medicine (HM), has had a rocky course. The more health care has become specialized, digitized, corporatized, and financialized, the greater the impression that HM operates only in the shadows. This sad eventuality was foreseen and bemoaned by both the conservative right and the radical left over 50 years ago, as the transformation from cottage industry to industrial ratrionalization began.i It is time to stop ignoring those old warnings and the present reality.
If HM is to be strengthened in current and future medical practice, we need to be more precise in defining what it consists of and why it is important; what individual skills and organizational conditions are required for it to be successfully practiced; how it can be measured; and what steps must be taken for implementing improvement.
The Definition of Humanistic Medicine
There
is no settled definition of HM.ii
We
think intuitively of humanistic medicine as a warm and fuzzy “bedside
manner,” comforting and caring. That is a good start. The famous
Francis Weld Peabody article of 1927 asserted that
“the way to care for the patient is to care for the patient,
getting to know the patient personally,” including
“the material and spiritual forces that bear on his life.”iii
Later definitions have been more precise,
as typically here:
“the physician’s attitudes and actions that demonstrate interest
in and respect for the patient and that address the patient’s
concerns and values. These generally are related to patients’
psychological, social, and spiritual domains.”iv
Another source cites the “Three C's”: “(HM's) main
components(are) 'comprehension' of the patient's narrative and
importantly – emotions; leading to 'compassion' and a 'commitment'
to act trying to help as much as possible.”v
These
definitions are informative guides to clinician
behaviors, but as
definitions of HM, they
have
two major shortcomings. (1) In
concentrating narrowly on the acts of the clinician, they omit the
contributions
of
other personnel, and of
the design
and functioning of the system of care itself. (2) The
definitions are exclusively
process-oriented,
assuming
that these behaviors will produce a beneficial outcome in all cases.
A
better definition would be this:
HM consists of all the
practices of the medical personnel and the system of care which lead
to the patient’s
feeling known, appreciated, and catered to as a specific individual,
and which make the patient feel cared for and cared about.
While
this
definition appropriately spotlights the effect on the patient, a
corollary
effect on the providers of HM should also be recognized. Humans
generally, and especially
people in medicine, feel
great satisfaction in giving to others.
So clinicians, other personnel, and even system planners and
managers themselves
benefit
from treating patients with high-level HM. In fact, it can give
significant meaning to their lives.
The Stakes of HM: Why Medicine Has Special Humanistic Needs
Medicine is not the only line of work with high stakes. Even common businesses often need to have good “customer relations.” Pursuits with higher stakes have even more need to relate personally and be trusted, including financial consultants, clergy, attorneys, police and others. Given the need for trust, most of these roles have developed codes of behavior and ethical constraints, including fidelity to truth, loyalty, fiduciary responsibility, and probity. Medicine has, arguably, the highest stakes most consistently of all jobs and professions. Medicine constantly confronts life, death, pain, disease, disability, anxiety, loss, rescue, risk, and anguish. Even routine visits evoke anxiety, and as severity increases, the choices made and the tragedy experienced can be excruciating. The medical role of healer has over centuries developed traditional codes of selfless caring, of putting the welfare of the patient above all other concerns, of not sleeping until the patient's needs are met, of respecting beneficence and non-maleficence, and (lately-added) respecting patient autonomy and justice.vi No pursuit quite matches the stakes of medicine. The ubiquity and seriousness of the intense personal issues in medicine compel us to realize that HM is a central concern to the mission of medicine, not a fringe issue.
The Content and Extent of HM Services
Beyond the definition of HM, understanding its substance requires examining its specifics in some detail. We can usefully divide the HM services into those of direct person to person contact on the one hand, and actions of the system on the other. The systematic actions can be subdivided into actions that affect patients directly or indirectly.
Person to person actions
The actions of many categories of personnel have bearing on HM. (See Figure 1). These include:
the individual seen as their main clinician by the patient (primary care or in some cases specialist)
members of the continuous clinician team (main clinician, on-call clinicians, advanced practice nurses and physicians' assistants, nurses, medical assistants, etc.)
hospitalists and members of a hospitalist team
members of a team for hospice, palliative care, pain care, addiction care, etc.
consultant clinicians (specialty referrals, radiologists, brief opinions)
technicians for laboratory and other tests and therapeutic services
non-clinical personnel for telephone calls, scheduling, reception, assistance, etc.
Each of these people can practice HM to different degrees. People in every job can demonstrate their competence with a caring attitude and they can affirmatively look for opportunities to do more to help. Brief visits with non-clinicians – laboratory technicians, scheduling staff – have requirements similar to the customer relations of other industries, with the added requirement of showing tenderness and compassion for the afflicted. Brief visits with consulting clinicians cannot encompass a deep knowledge of the patient as an entire person, but warmth of manner and a benignant attitude can lead to surprisingly touching interactions. The more longitudinal relationships between patients and clinicians and office personnel present opportunities for deeper relationships and more manifestly personal caring and understanding, as is traditionally understood.
For all clinicians, the key component of the relationship has been known as the doctor-patient relationship, but with team medicine now being widely practiced, it should be renamed the clinician-patient relationship. The keystone of a successful clinician-patient relationship is to discover where on the continuum between active-passive, guidance-cooperation, and mutual participation each individual relationship lies.vii Additionally, deciding on the characterization of the relationship as paternalistic, informative, interpretive, or deliberative is a useful alternative classification.viii The choices are constrained not only by the clinical situation, but by the desires and capabilities of each party. The usual ideal relationship is now considered to be mutual participation, but this needs to be individualized. Some patients prefer paternalism, some clinicians are unable to be mutually participative, some relationships are easier than others, different stages of illness can require a changed relationship, etc. Each relationship requires sorting out, good matches of clinician to patient are important, and each relationship needs to be individualized. There is no magic key that fits everyone. This is what makes HM so hard – there are guidelines, but each relationship is another experiment.
Erected on the base of the clinician-patient relationship are the tasks for each specific case, many of which are hard to master. For example, delivering bad news is always hard, and always dependent on the relationship.ix Deriving the meaning of illness in the life of the patient – sometimes addressed directly by narrative medicine and spiritual medicine – is as complex as the human spirit.x xi Indeed, many clinicians report that their skill in HM increases nearly every year they are in practice. Just to examine this incomplete list of tasks is to appreciate both the centrality of HM to medical practice, and the difficulty of mastering these tasks.
Organizational actions
The way organizations are set up to function, whether patient-experience-first or organizational-convenience-first, determines how patients perceive the concern of organizations for them personally.
The direct effects of organizations on HM are obvious in everyday interactions. The organization controls choice of primary clinician and specialist, access to caregivers and testing, communications with caregivers, coordination of care, and other functions. Examples would be:
Are telephone calls made easily, or are long and complex phone trees and often problemmatic AI assistants encountered? How difficult is it to contact an actual human being?
Are appointments made easily and timely, or (for instance) is a patient with a new cancer diagnosis made to wait in psychological anguish many weeks for a first appointment because the system does not privilege urgency for patients who have not seen this specific clinician previously?
Is continuity of care respected, and are various specialists and tests all coordinated in a patient-centered way, are “warm handoffs” and clinician to clinician telephone conferences facilitated, is there always someone for the patient to turn to for personal help, is there a “sherpa” to facilitate workups and make appointments and to constantly reorient patients as needed, or are patients left in the lurch of apparent disorganization to fend for themselves?
When a patient is hospitalized, are they served solely by hospitalists who know little about them as persons and who find it hard to organize themselves for HM, or are provisions made for continuity of HM care, possibly involving their long-standing clinicians (whose visits are not now paid for, because insurance deems these “social visits”)?xii Do hospital clinicians make an effective effort to contact in a timely fashion both the patient, the family, and the PCP?
Is the referral procedure set up so that PCP’s can fully exercise their medical fiduciary function in choosing the best referral for the patient in the area, or are there significant constraints so that patients are funneled only within a network?
Are the 20% of patients who consume 80% of resources affirmatively targeted for special support and preventive attention?
Are facilities adapted to high HM standards – parking, greeting, directing, on-time performance?
Organizational owners and leaders, system designers, software designers, human relations departments, managers and others are in charge of all these items of HM.
The indirect effects of organizations refer to how they encourage or constrain individual interactions. Each element of these person to person medical relationships takes time, attention, resources, incentives, and trained ability. The desire to deliver HM often derives simply from the personality and values of the clinicians and other staff – they went into medicine for a reason, often including a desire to help people. But it is the organizational setting that determines whether that latent desire is supported or suppressed.
Is the length of an appointment tailored to individual needs, or is every patient wedged into the routine average time of a visit?
Are acute visits made timely with the care team, or are patients routinely directed to visit urgent care or ER on their own?
Are clinicians incentivized to deliver high HM care, both by payment and by recognition and support for their HM efforts?
Are non-clinical staff trained in customer service?
Is the Electronic Health Record an impediment or an aid to the clinician-patient relationship? Is there a section in it for social and psychological history and progress? Is the medical record easily shared with patients in an understandable way?xiii
Are other electronic aids used to promote continuity and continuous contact with the patient?
Are administrative and charting loads minimized so that clinicians have time to devote to HM?
Is the clinicians’ job structured for optimal job satisfaction, avoiding overwork and moral injury?xiv
Looking at all the factors that contribute to HM, it is clearly an all-of-system phenomenon, not just a compassionate and understanding doctor.
Finances
If HM is the health care system’s showing care and concern for the individual patient, certainly paying for care has strong implications for HM. Should a patient worry about getting care because of financial implications, be it copays, deductibles, medical debt or medical bankruptcy, choosing between medical care or food or housing, or other consequences? If one believes that health care is like any other good or service in life, like buying a new television or deciding on a vacation, then one can justify financial consequences, including possible avoidance of care or medicines and choosing inferior treatments. But if one believes that health care is special, like having food to eat or housing to live in or education to pursue, then one is likely to be persuaded that facing more than small financial consequences of seeking care violates HM. An intake clerk’s asking for the patient’s insurance coverage as the first order of business, and receiving a huge and possibly unexpected bill for services rendered are certainly experiences that violate the spirit of HM.
Some will object that financial consequences are important to moderate demand. Yet, financial consequences fall inequitably – the wealthy are little affected, Medicaid recipients have little financial responsibility, some others have excellent insurance, while the bulk of the middle and the lower middle classes are those most dissuaded from seeking care, or most affected financially when they must seek care. In addition, the main culprits for high costs in health care are not high utilization, but rather high prices in hospitals and in procedures, for drugs, and for administrative overhead, Out patient utilization is a minor factor in health care costs, and asking patients to shop for prices for health care is unrealistic and financially nugatory. xv
HM considerations demand that financial implications for health care be a minor issue for patients, and that medical decisions by families not have to take finances into account. National and state politics and policies, insurance company practices and policies, and medical systems and office policies and directives all have a hand in making financing either supportive or toxic with respect to HM.
Implementation
Understanding and valuing HM is important and indispensable, but implementation does not automatically follow recognition.xvi Implementation depends on the relative weights of support for or impediments to change.
Technical ability to change to high level HM
The technical means to achieve high level HM already exist for the most part. Although the clinical workforce could use much more HM training, and although most organizations would need extensive adjustments in rendering all the systems patient-centric, and although the invention of electronic apps would be very helpful in making HM operations easier and more automatic; nonetheless, the tools necessary for high level HM exist right now. It’s just a question of using them.
Indeed, high level HM is operating in many places already. Some clinicians and their offices deliver high level HM even within current systems, and some systems are reasonably patient-centric; these examples are just not widespread. Executive health programs often have high-touch care with strong availability and enhanced navigation as standard features. Elite specialty clinics often manage to be both efficient and patient centered. Many concierge primary care practices take time with patients and provide excellent availability, although they often cannot direct patients well once they are in the hands of medical bureaucracies.xvii Companies have arisen that help patients navigate the current system (the sherpa function) for a fee. In fact, one might say that HM currently exists, but only for the chosen few. To some extent, then, the challenge might be seen as how to take these efforts to scale, and to make HM the rule rather than the exception.
A glaring missing tool – sufficient measurement
The most conspicuous missing tool for HM is the capacity to measure it. Current measures are rudimentary, based mostly on patient feedback forms filled out after visits. One assessment concludes that “(w)ithout reform, current survey practices might continue inflicting burnout on physicians and bad medical care on patients.”xviii Measures are needed to help describe productivity, guide improvements, and differentiate one enterprise from another. By working together and using all three of the categories of quality developed by Donabedian, imaginative clinicians, patients, and health services researchers should be up to the task of devising measures that can be unobtrusively and efficiently gathered to describe HM in all its variety.xix (see Figure 2)
In measurement, practicality counts. "Not everything that counts can be counted, and not everything that can be counted counts." (William Bruce Cameron.) Inferences must sometimes be made. “It is better to be roughly right than precisely wrong.” (John Maynard Keynes). Paying for each individual component of HM care should not be the goal; rather, the objective should be to be able to gather enough information efficiently to stratify practices and systems into general levels of HM accomplishment.
A glaring challenge: motivation to change
The second challenge is the most obvious and the most daunting. What would inspire practices and systems to undertake the time, effort, and cost to enhance their HM?
On the positive side:
Idealism is alive in medicine, not only among clinicians, but in staff and enterprise leaders themselves. If scientists can strive for years hoping for The Prize, then surely those in health care delivery can strive for excellence in HM. Indeed, some insist that fighting for HM is fighting for the profession itself.xx Creation of various forms of recognition – medals similar to combat medals, certificates, prizes similar to the Baldrige Prize, would be essential to stimulate this motivational resource.
Employee satisfaction is closely associated with idealism. HM motivates clinicians, who feel less anomie and moral injury where high HM exists. Retaining and attracting clinicians is especially vital in the era of primary care crisis.xxi
Patient satisfaction engendered by HM is not only a good thing in and of itself, but it leads to retaining and attracting patients, especially in geographical areas of true competition.
The prestige of the enterprise, especially if buttressed by public recognition of superior HR, leads not only to psychological satisfaction, but also to economic advantage in negotiations.
On the more problemmatic side, however, is finances. Would enhancing HR cost more money than it made, and if it were actually profitable, would it be profitable enough to warrant the effort? The answer is, no one knows, but financially, under current conditions, it would probably be a net negative. Reengineering organizational processes to be patient service focused would probably not prove to be ultimately costly. Clinically, however, if personnel spend more time per patient, their financial productivity would dip, since the payment system of Resource Based Relative Value Scale (RBRVS) disproportionately rewards number of visits and procedures over time spent.xxii In addition, more adjunctive clinical personnel with their attendant costs would probably be necessary. Even in organizations that are supported by capitated payments, Relative Value Units (RVUs) generated by the RBRVS system are utilized internally to track supposed productivity, and thus HM efforts are judged as lack of efficiency rather than as elements of productivity.
Few enterprises will pursue increased HM, no matter how enticing the idealistic banefits, it the anticipated financial consequences would be negative. It is therefore imperative, if HM is to be implemented, that ways be found to make enhanced HM profitble. How can this be done?
Enterprises in competitive environments can capitalize on improved HM by gaining more patients through better HM.
Increased HM quality can accompany increased efficiency.
Patient-centered reforms in patient flow can both improve service and make the processes more efficient.xxiii
Likewise with improvements to clinician communications.
Increased substitution of work by adjunctive members of the clinical team can reduce PCP direct involvement and thus increase productivity.
Payment systems can be changed.
RBRVS codes can be changed to fully recognize HM services.
Payors can recognize different levels of HM service assigned to care providers. Both fee-for-service and capitated systems can receive enhanced payments pari passu with higher HM scores.
Insurance companies can be mandated to cover the payments for HM, and not be allowed to cherry pick the codes and levels of HM that they will pay.
National directives on criteria for ratings of systems (the star system for Medicare Advantage) can be changed to include HM measures, improving patient attraction.
The misleading arguments against HM as being “too costly”
One other source of resistance to enhancing HM is the argument that our system of medical care is already so costly that considering taking on more expense would be irresponsible. This argument fails on several counts. The extra expense of strengthening HM should be moderate, and might even save money overall. HM is underfunded at present; the real sources of current excessive cost are excessive concentration with lack of both competition and regulation. This has led to extremely high prices system wide, especially in hospital care, pharmaceuticals, and procedures. Our insurance system and other problems have engendered extremely excessive costs in administration as well. Our concentration on specialist care to the exclusion of a strong primary care system has also led to excessive expense. It makes no sense to compensate for these excesses and distortions in other parts of the system by skimping on the neglected but vital sector of HM.
Policy Proposals
Finally, for HM to be implemented, policy changes are needed at all levels. Here are some suggestions:
1. Everything starts with declared intention. Medical schools, residencies, fellowship programs, and health care delivery enterprises should formally acknowledge not only the goal of excellence in BioM, but also the goal of excellence in HM.
Fiscal objectives, a third goal, should become more of a constraint to be fiscally responsible, rather than a goal to be maximized.
All efforts in instruction and testing should reflect the BioM and HM priorities.
Organizational activities should faithfully reflect the HM goal, including budgeting, assignment of personnel, tracking progress, etc.
HM interested groups within organizations should organize themselves to press the organizations to adopt HM as a primary goal
2. The relevant health divisions of the federal government should similarly adopt HM goals as part of their mission, especially aiming at:
research on HM measurements
research on introducing HM to both academic and health care delivery institutions
promotion of HM knowledge
rewarding HM achievements with awards
development of techniques to make HM improvement profitable, especially including payments for superior HM care
assessment of HM in institutions and local areas and communicating the information to the institutions and the public
replacing the RBRVS system with alternative methods of payment and productivity assessment
3. Health care researchers and their funders should consider HM related subjects of study, particularly measurement.
4. Innovation in electronic and other devices that enable and strengthen HM should receive special financial inducements from both government and private sources. (See Figure 3)
5. Recognition and prizes for HM achievements should be issued to schools of medicine, other training units, and health care providing enterprises, borth routinely and for special achievements. Routine recognition would be like earned military ribbons and medals. Special recognition would be high awards for excellence, similar to The Baldridge Award for businesses.
6. The federal government should pledge that all of its policies, including HM measurements, will be neutral in affecting the size of enterprises, providing a level playing field as smaller practices compete against larger enterprises.
Conclusion
BioM and HM are two sides of the same coin. Their combined weight totals the effectiveness and quality of medical care. Neither must be neglected. The contributions of BioM to health are more easily appreciated and measured than the contributions of HM, which are far more extensive and difficult to master than often recognized. Redefining HM as patient centered caring delivered at both the personal and organizational level gives more depth to HM than older definitions. Both training institutions and care-giving institutions should make HM a co-equal goal with BioM in their missions. Implementation of HM will require the development of measures of HM; the adoption of HM as formal goals by government and by academic and health care delivery institutions; and the devotion of resources devoted to achieve that end. Policies should be adopted at several levels so that HM is financially incentivized rather than disincentivized.
Figure 1 - Clinician HM Responsibilities
|
Patient Condition |
Clinician Tasks, examples |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Level 1 – usual routine relationship with usual prevention and illnesses |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
establishing trust through honesty, transparency, sensitivity, human connection, skillful communications, authenticity |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
eliciting key psychological, cultural, belief, social, and economic conditions of patient |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
being skillful in allaying anxiety |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
on occasion reaching intimacy probing for what fits best for patients |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
being skillful in dealing with the difficult patient |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Level 2 – increasingly serious illness |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
how to break the news of a difficult diagnosis and prognosis |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
how to grant autonomy but also take professional responsibility |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
being medical fiduciary in finding best care, despite network restrictions |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
optimism under pressure |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
continue mutual participation in charting course |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Level 3 – very serious illness |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
honesty and transparency |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
how to share expectations for dangerous operation |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
how to move to hospice or comfort care |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
negotiating with other dogged clinicians who want to cure |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
making sense of the ordeal through narrative medicine and spiritual medicine |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
dealing with the family who says “do everything” |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
what to do when there is nothing to be done |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
never abandoning patient |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Level 4 – impending and actual death |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
facing it together |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
the wisdom of the doctor applied |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
calling in the chaplain |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
activating the planned advanced directive |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
acting as a team |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
medical assistance in dying |
|
|
|
|
|
Figure 2 - HM Measurement Development Examples
|
Characteristic |
structure |
process |
outcome |
|
Help making appts with tests or specialists |
app is on practice computers; staff is trained |
how many times app has been used |
appointments obtained timely (e.g., within a week obtained 90% of time) |
|
Help navigating course of treatment |
app is being utilized; f/u be staff in place |
number of encounters; number of times staff have called patients on their own |
patient evaluations |
|
Out of network referrals |
Software adapted to task |
|
Ratio of in-network to out-of-network referrals |
|
General empathy and warmth |
credentials of staff — recent training, staff conferences, extra time scheduled for crucial visits (dynamic scheduling); incentives in place |
how many extra minutes allowed, number of times staff has reached out, etc. |
Patient questionnaire responses to specific questions; specific complaints and responses |
|
Parking |
availability, cost, concierge, disability |
|
Patient questionnaire responses |
|
|
|
|
|
Figure 3 — HM Possible Inventions for Enhanced HM
|
AI in exam room to fill out EHR, relieve clinician from data input duty |
|
Program EHR to group personal details and construct a social and psychological portrait of the patient from what was said in visits — instead of editing this data out, as current AI records are said to do |
|
AI to make medical record instantly available to patients and family in lay language at various levels of understanding |
|
App to guide patients through care labyrinth, making appointments, displaying workup map, coordinating hospitalist—PCP conversations |
|
App to enable real time hospitalist—PCP conversations — specialist conversations enabling warm handoffs |
|
|
i Halberstam MJ. Liberal thought, radical theory, and medical practice. N Eng J Med 1971;284:1180-1185.
iiFerry-Danini J. A new path for humanistic medicine. Theor Med Bioeth 2018; 39: 57-77.
iiiPeabody FW. The care of the patient. JAMA, 1927; 88: 877-882
ivBranch WT, Kern D, Haidet P, et al. Teaching the human dimensions of care in clinical settings. JAMA 2001; 286(9):1067-1074.
vSchattner A. The Essence of Humanistic Medicine. QJM, An International Journal of Medicine, Volume 113, Issue 1, January 2020, Pages 3–4.
viBeauchamp, T. L., & Childress, J. F. (2019). Principles of biomedical ethics (8th ed.). Oxford University Press.
viiSzasz TS, Hollender H, A Contribution to the Philosophy of medicine:The Basic Models of the Doctor-Patient Relationship. AMA Arch Intern Med 1956;97;(5):585-592.
viiiEmanuel EJ, Emanuel LL. Four models of the physician-patient relationship. JAMA 1992, 267: 221-2226
ixSulmasy DP. Physicians, spirituality, and compassionate patient care. N Engl J Med 2024, 390: 1061-1063.
x Long KNG, Symons X, VenderWeele TJ, et al. Spirituality As A Determinant Of Health: Emerging Policies, Practices, And Systems. Health Affairs 2024,43: 783-790
xiCharon R. Narrative Medicine: A model for empathy, reflection, profession, and trust. JAMA 2001: 1897-1902.
xiiGilsdorf JR. No one in charge. N Engl J Med 2024, 391: 974-975.
xiiiShenkin BN. Open notes in the context of humanistic medicine. J Peds Clin Prac 2025, 17:
xivDean W, Morris D, Llorca P-M, et al. Moral injury and the global workforce health crisis – insights from from an international partnership. N Engl J Med 2024,391: 782-785.
xvPolicy Statement of the American Academy of Pediatrics, Pediatrics, High Deductible Health Plans, PEDIATRICS Volume 133, Number 5, May 2014 e1461-70.
xviPressman JL, Wildavsky AB, Implementation: How great expectations in Washington are dashed in Oakland. University of California Press, Berkeley, CA, 1973
xvii La Forgia A. From patients to consumers – the corporatization of ambulatory care. NEJM 2026, 394: 1-3.
xviii Richman BD, Schulman KA. Are patient satisfaction instruments harming both patients and physicians?” JAMA 2022, 328: 2209-2210.
xixDonabedian A. Evaluating the quality of medical care. The Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly, Vol. 44, No. 3, Pt. 2, 1966 (pp. 166–203).
xxSawatsky AP, Leep Underfund An. Health care’s identify crisis – Is medicine still a profession? JAMA 2006; 336: 1503-1506.
xxiCahan E. Inside the growing crisis of primary care. JAMA 2026, 336:1590-1593.
xxiiMcMahon Jr. LF, Song Zirui. Rebuilding the relative value unit-based phyisician payment system. JAMA 2024, 332: 369-370.
xxiii Ganguli I. How does health care burden patients? Let me count the days. N Engl J Med 2024,391: 880-883.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
No comments:
Post a Comment